October 14, 2012

more Sunday reading . . .

We got trouble right here in River City - except our professor didn't concoct the trouble he is warning us about. We need to band together and learn some new tunes. Nicholas Carnes, an assistant professor of public policy at Duke University and author of the forthcoming book “White-Collar Government: How Class-Imbalanced Legislatures Distort Economic Policy-Making in the United States,” tells us about the choices we really have.
Elections are supposed to give us choices. We can reward incumbents or we can throw the bums out. We can choose Republicans or Democrats. We can choose conservative policies or progressive ones.

In most elections, however, we don’t get a say in something important: whether we’re governed by the rich. By Election Day, that choice has usually been made for us. Would you like to be represented by a millionaire lawyer or a millionaire businessman? Even in our great democracy, we rarely have the option to put someone in office who isn’t part of the elite.

If millionaires were a political party, that party would make up roughly 3 percent of American families, but it would have a super-majority in the Senate, a majority in the House, a majority on the Supreme Court and a man in the White House. If working-class Americans were a political party, that party would have made up more than half the country since the start of the 20th century. But legislators from that party (those who last worked in blue-collar jobs before entering politics) would never have held more than 2 percent of the seats in Congress.

2 comments:

  1. Carnes's observations in this piece highlight yet another aspect of just how illicit the US electoral process really is. I would only add that government by the "elites" has been with us since earliest colonial times, long before the Revolution. Indeed, many of our most revered Founding Fathers, including James Madison and Alexander Hamilton, explicitly advocated such arrangements.

    Clearly, we've always had government of the people, but very little, if any, government by the people or for the people. For a revealing portrayal why this is so and of how American government, at all levels, really works and for whom it works, I cannot recommend highly enough William Greider's Who Will Tell The People? Though published in 1992, it has dated very little; the main difference is that the conditions he described then are even more pervasive and pernicious today. Read it, and weep.

    ReplyDelete
  2. oh yes, we sure got trouble here in river city. it is an illusion that we have a government of the people by the people and for the people. we have a government of the powerful/rich people for the powerful/rich people who have us all believing that we the regular folk have a say in the matter. the military industrial complex is pulling all the strings in this flat world.
    jv

    ReplyDelete